The most painful trade the Dodgers could make at the 2025 Winter Meetings is moving veteran infielder Max Muncy.
While the logical, less-painful move centers on top prospect Dalton Rushing (who is blocked by Will Smith) or a young outfielder like Andy Pages, trading Muncy would be a gut punch to the heart of the Dodgers’ dynasty-era clubhouse and fanbase.
The Painful Logic
The pain of trading Muncy comes from the emotional loss, not the practical necessity, yet a compelling utilitarian argument exists for moving the veteran slugger:
- Emotional Core: Muncy is one of the longest-tenured, most beloved players on the roster. He has been integral to every championship push since 2018 and is a proven clubhouse leader. Trading him, especially after winning back-to-back titles, would feel cold and transactional.
- The Financial Bargain: Muncy is only making $10 million for the 2026 season (after the Dodgers picked up his option), an absolute bargain for a veteran who can still provide 20+ home run power and elite plate discipline.
- Creating Space for an Upgrade: The Dodgers desperately need a defensive upgrade at third base and want to create room for rumored trade targets like Brendan Donovan (Cardinals) or potentially a free agent.
- The Age Factor: Muncy is one of the oldest everyday position players on the roster, and the Dodgers are looking to inject more athleticism and youth into the infield, paving the way for top prospect Alex Freeland or a major defensive acquisition.
The Shocking Alternative: Teoscar Hernández
Another trade that would cause shockwaves is dealing newly acquired outfielder Teoscar Hernández. Reports indicate that his name is surprisingly not being shot down in trade talks.
- The Astonishment: Hernández was brought in to bolster the outfield. Trading him now would suggest the Dodgers have a secret, bigger move planned (like signing Kyle Tucker or trading for Steven Kwan) and are using Hernández to acquire the necessary pitching depth or clear a roster spot. This would be a shocking reversal of their offseason strategy.
While Rushing is the most logical trade piece, moving the established, emotional veteran Max Muncy would be the one that truly leaves the fanbase “appalled” and defines the 2025 Winter Meetings as the moment the Dodgers prioritized business over sentiment.
