The Guardians’ pitching looks closer to elite than the headlines admit, and their biggest advantage might be the most repeatable one.NL

When it comes to building a contender, the Cleveland Guardians don’t follow the typical big-market blueprint. They’re not out here handing out $300 million contracts or making splashy moves just to win the offseason headlines. Instead, they’ve carved out a different identity-one rooted in smart scouting, player development, and, perhaps most impressively, bullpen efficiency that borders on elite.

Let’s talk about that bullpen for a second. Because while it may not be stacked with household names, it’s delivering results that any front office would envy-and at a fraction of the cost.

In fact, Cleveland’s top three late-inning arms-closer Cade Smith and setup men Hunter Gaddis and Erik Sabrowski-are set to make just $2.34 million combined in 2026. That’s not just value; that’s borderline wizardry in today’s market.

And these aren’t just innings-eaters. These guys are producing at a high level.

Cade Smith, who took over closing duties, has emerged as a legitimate force at the back end of games. He posted a 2.42 ERA, but the real eye-opener is his 1.67 FIP-suggesting his performance wasn’t just good, it was sustainable. Add in a 5.4 fWAR, and you’re looking at one of the most valuable relievers in baseball, regardless of salary.

Hunter Gaddis, the righty setup man, has been rock solid as well. His 2.29 ERA and 3.14 FIP show he’s more than just a bridge to the ninth-he’s a high-leverage weapon in his own right. With a 2.5 fWAR, Gaddis has given Cleveland quality innings and consistency, two things every manager craves in a setup role.

Then there’s Erik Sabrowski, the left-handed complement who’s quietly been one of the most effective relievers in the game. A 1.29 ERA and 2.86 FIP don’t lie-Sabrowski has been nails when called upon. His 0.7 fWAR may not jump off the page, but in the matchups he’s been asked to handle, he’s done the job.

What makes this even more impressive is how Cleveland has managed to keep this unit performing at a high level over multiple seasons. That’s a testament to their coaching staff-particularly the pitching coaches-who continue to develop arms and put them in positions to succeed. The Guardians have built a bullpen that’s not just effective, but adaptable, and that’s no small feat in a league where reliever performance can fluctuate wildly from year to year.

Looking ahead, the Guardians are in a strong position. With their core bullpen arms locked in at bargain prices, they’ve got financial flexibility to add reinforcements this offseason. A couple of fresh arms could give them the depth they need to weather a long season and stay near the top of the American League.

No, Cleveland doesn’t spend like the Yankees or Dodgers. But they don’t need to. They’ve found their own formula for success-one that’s built on efficiency, development, and a bullpen that continues to punch well above its weight.