Nobody Was Ready for What Jelly Roll Shared on Live TV—A Truth That Left the Idol Judges Visibly Shaken. ML
One of the most emotional moments of the 2025 American Idol season came when Jelly Roll, acting as the show’s inaugural Artist in Residence, honored 18-year-old John Foster. The young singer from Addis, Louisiana, touched the hearts of many with “Tell That Angel I Love Her,” an original song paying tribute to his friends Maggie Dunn and Caroline Gill, who tragically passed away in a 2022 car accident.
Jelly Roll, known for his emotionally honest music, was visibly impacted by Foster’s performance. During the episode, he read a personal letter to Foster on air, expressing how deeply moved he was. “John, your performance touched my soul,” the letter began. “The depth of your emotion and the sincerity in your voice reminded me of why I fell in love with music in the first place.”
He continued, “In a world where authenticity is rare, you stand out as a beacon of truth. Your ability to channel your pain into something beautiful is a testament to your strength and artistry.”
The reading prompted an emotional response from both the audience and judges, many of whom were seen in tears. Carrie Underwood praised Foster’s performance, noting his emotional delivery and traditional country influence.
Jelly Roll’s presence on the show has introduced a meaningful layer of emotional support. His mentorship goes beyond music, showing how deep connections can form when artists open up about their personal journeys.
Moments like this one serve as reminders of American Idol’s ongoing mission to celebrate more than just musical ability. Foster’s heartfelt tribute—and the connection it sparked—underscores the show’s focus on storytelling, healing, and the enduring power of music.
