Behind the Music: Jelly Roll’s Unread Letter to John Foster Turns American Idol Into a Stage for Something Deeper. ML
A deeply emotional moment unfolded during the 2025 season of American Idol when Jelly Roll, the show’s first-ever Artist in Residence, honored 18-year-old John Foster following his moving performance. Foster, from Addis, Louisiana, performed his original song, “Tell That Angel I Love Her,” in tribute to two close friends, Maggie Dunn and Caroline Gill, who died in a tragic car crash in 2022.
Jelly Roll, celebrated for his authentic and heartfelt music, was clearly affected by the performance. He shared a letter on-air, expressing admiration for Foster’s vulnerability and emotional strength. “John, your performance touched my soul,” he wrote. “The sincerity in your voice reminded me of why I fell in love with music in the first place.”
He continued, “In a world where authenticity is rare, you stand out as a beacon of truth. Your ability to transform pain into beauty shows your incredible strength as an artist.”
The heartfelt exchange resonated with the entire studio audience and judges, many of whom were seen tearing up. Judge Carrie Underwood commended Foster’s traditional country sound and emotional depth, highlighting his distinctive voice.
Jelly Roll’s role as Artist in Residence has brought more than just mentorship—it’s brought genuine emotional support. His connection with Foster showed how music can create a bond between people through shared grief and honesty.
As the show moves forward, Foster’s story adds to American Idol’s commitment to highlighting authentic talent and human resilience. His journey is a moving example of how music can help us process loss and express the inexpressible.
